On April 21, 2025, the Indian government imposed a 12% provisional safeguard duty on imports of certain non-alloy and alloy steel flat products, effective for 200 days, to curb the influx of low-cost steel, particularly from China and Vietnam. This trade remedy, announced by the Ministry of Finance, sparked a rally in metal stocks on April 22, 2025, with the Nifty Metal Index gaining 1.5%. Major steel producers, including Tata Steel, JSW Steel, Steel Authority of India (SAIL), and Jindal Steel and Power (JSPL), saw their shares surge as investors cheered the protective measure. Recommended by the Directorate General of Trade Remedies (DGTR), the duty aims to shield domestic manufacturers from a surge in imports threatening market stability. This article examines the safeguard duty, its impact on the steel industry, the market’s response, and the broader implications for India’s economy, while critically assessing the measure’s effectiveness and potential drawbacks.
The Surge in Steel Imports: A Growing Concern
India, the world’s second-largest crude steel producer, has faced mounting pressure from rising steel imports, which hit a nine-year high of 9.5 million metric tons in FY25, up 15% from 8.3 million tons in FY24, according to provisional government data. The Indian Steel Association (ISA), representing companies like ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel India, JSW Steel, and SAIL, highlighted that imports, primarily from China, South Korea, Japan, and Vietnam, were eroding domestic market share and profitability. Between April 2024 and January 2025, flat steel product imports surged 22%, pushing domestic prices to three-year lows.
The surge has been partly attributed to global trade distortions, notably the United States’ 25% tariff on steel imports, escalated under President Donald Trump’s policies since 2018. These tariffs diverted excess Chinese steel to markets like India, where cheap imports threatened to flood the market, especially after Trump’s April 2025 tariff hikes to 245% on Chinese goods. The DGTR’s investigation, initiated in December 2024 following an ISA complaint, confirmed a “recent, sudden, sharp, and significant increase” in imports, causing “serious injury” to domestic producers. The ISA noted that China’s shift from long to flat steel products, driven by declining domestic demand, exacerbated the issue.
Details of the Safeguard Duty
The 12% provisional safeguard duty, effective from April 21, 2025, targets five steel flat product categories: hot-rolled coils, sheets, and plates; hot-rolled plate mill plates; cold-rolled coils and sheets; metallic coated steel coils and sheets; and colour-coated coils and sheets. The duty applies to imports priced below USD 675–964 per ton on a cost, insurance, and freight (CIF) basis, exempting higher-value shipments to ensure premium products remain unaffected. Developing countries, except China and Vietnam, are excluded, aligning with India’s trade commitments.
The DGTR’s March 18, 2025, recommendation emphasised the urgency of the measure, warning that delays could cause “irreparable damage” to the domestic industry. The duty, a World Trade Organisation (WTO)-sanctioned trade remedy, is distinct from anti-dumping duties as it applies uniformly across countries, addressing sudden import surges rather than predatory pricing. Union Steel Minister H.D. Kumaraswamy hailed the move, stating, “The safeguard duty will provide critical relief to domestic producers, especially small and medium-scale enterprises, restoring market stability”. ISA President Naveen Jindal added, “This step will protect Indian manufacturers from unfair imports and boost domestic production”.
Market Response: A Rally in Metal Stocks
The safeguard duty announcement triggered a broad-based rally in metal stocks on April 22, 2025. The Nifty Metal Index rose 1.22% to 8,759 by 9:30 AM, hitting an intraday high of 8,783, marking its sixth consecutive session of gains. The BSE Metal Index also climbed 1.5%, outperforming the flat Sensex and Nifty 50. All 15 constituents of the Nifty Metal Index traded in the green, reflecting strong investor optimism.
Key performers included:
- Tata Steel: Shares surged 2.6% to ₹142.85, leading the sector.
- SAIL: Gained 2.5% to ₹117.44.
- Jindal Stainless: Rose 1.64% to ₹659.70.
- Jindal Steel and Power (JSPL): Advanced 1.9% to ₹914.70.
- JSW Steel: Edged up 1.28% to ₹1,037.80.
- Hindustan Copper: Climbed 1.64% to ₹223.93.
- Hindustan Zinc: Gained 1.33% to ₹441.80.
- NALCO: Rose 1.6% to ₹163.90.
Other gainers included Vedanta, Hindalco Industries, NMDC, and Adani Enterprises, with gains of 0.2–1.3%. Posts on X captured the bullish sentiment, with one user stating, “Steel Stocks on Fire 🔥 Govt imposes 12% safeguard duty on select imports. Big positive for 🇮🇳 players like SAIL, JSW Steel, Tata Steel, JSPL”.
Industry and Analyst Perspectives
Industry leaders welcomed the duty as a critical step to restore fair competition. T.V. Narendran, CEO of Tata Steel, called it “a critical step in addressing the surge of unfairly priced imports,” emphasising its role in ensuring the industry’s long-term sustainability. Naveen Jindal of JSPL noted that the duty would counter “predatory pricing” by foreign producers.
Brokerages were largely positive but cautious. JPMorgan stated that the duty would support domestic steelmakers, while CLSA raised target prices for JSW Steel and Tata Steel, citing improved demand prospects amid China’s economic stimulus. Kotak Institutional Equities noted that Indian steel producers are better positioned than aluminium producers, expecting margin stability due to the duty and easing coking coal prices.
However, Morgan Stanley tempered expectations, arguing that while the duty removes uncertainty, it is unlikely to drive significant price hikes. Domestic hot-rolled coil (HRC) prices, trading at an 18% premium to import parity, would only see a 5% premium post-duty, limiting earnings upside. The brokerage advised using the rally to pare positions, suggesting the measure’s impact may be short-lived.
Critical Analysis: Benefits and Challenges
The safeguard duty offers several benefits to India’s steel industry:
- Protection for Domestic Producers: By curbing low-cost imports, the duty supports major players like Tata Steel and SAIL, as well as smaller enterprises, stabilising prices and improving capacity utilisation.
- Margin Stability: The duty, combined with easing input costs like coking coal, could bolster EBITDA margins, which range from 9–23% for major producers.
- Boost to Self-Reliance: The measure aligns with India’s “Atmanirbhar Bharat” vision, reducing dependence on imports and supporting the National Steel Policy’s goal of 300 million tons of crude steel capacity by 2030.
However, the duty has sparked debate, with downstream industries and analysts raising concerns:
- Impact on MSMES and Exporters: The Federation of Indian Export Organisations (FIEO) warned that the duty could raise domestic steel prices from ₹5,400 to ₹6,000 per ton, hurting engineering exports, especially given U.S. tariffs. MSMES fear higher input costs could erode competitiveness.
- Risk of Monopolistic Practices: The Global Trade Research Initiative (GTRI) cautioned that the duty could encourage domestic producers to inflate prices, limiting consumer choices and contradicting India’s trade liberalisation policies.
- Limited Price Upside: As Morgan Stanley noted, the duty may not significantly lift domestic prices due to existing premiums, potentially capping earnings growth.
- Trade Agreement Tensions: With 70–80% of India’s steel imports coming via free trade agreements (FTAS) with Japan and South Korea, the duty may strain trade relations.
The GTRI also criticised the DGTR’s methodology, arguing that using a COVID-affected base year misrepresented the import surge as abnormal, given healthy industry margins. This raises questions about the duty’s necessity and proportionality.
Broader Economic and Global Context
The safeguard duty reflects broader global trade dynamics. The U.S.’s protectionist policies have reshaped steel trade flows, with countries like the European Union, South Africa, Turkey, Vietnam, and Malaysia imposing similar barriers since 2018. India’s move aligns with these efforts to counter trade diversion, but it must balance protectionism with its WTO commitments and FTA obligations.
Domestically, the duty supports India’s steel production, which reached 149 million tons in 2024, with plans to expand significantly. However, the steel trade deficit, at a 10-year high of 4.5 million tons in FY25, underscores the challenge of balancing imports and exports. The duty may help narrow this gap, but it risks inflating costs for steel-dependent sectors like automotive, construction, and infrastructure.
Implications for Investors and the Industry
For investors, the rally in metal stocks presents opportunities but also risks. The duty has boosted sentiment, as seen in the Nifty Metal Index’s six-session winning streak. However, experts like Zee Business’s Singhvi advise caution, warning of profit booking at higher levels. Long-term investors may benefit from focusing on fundamentally strong companies like Tata Steel and JSW Steel, which are well-positioned to leverage domestic demand and policy support.
For the industry, the duty provides breathing room to address import pressures, but producers must improve efficiency and innovation to compete globally. The government’s role in monitoring price hikes and ensuring inflation remains within target ranges will be critical, as noted by Harsh Bansal of BMW Industries.
Conclusion
The Indian government’s imposition of a 12% safeguard duty on steel imports has sparked a rally in metal stocks, with companies like Tata Steel, SAIL, JSW Steel, and JSPL benefiting from renewed investor confidence. The measure, effective for 200 days from April 21, 2025, addresses a surge in low-cost imports threatening domestic producers, driven by global trade distortions and excess capacity in China and other nations. While the duty supports India’s steel industry and aligns with its self-reliance goals, it has raised concerns about higher costs for MSMES, potential trade tensions, and limited price upside.
Critically, the duty’s effectiveness depends on its implementation and the industry’s ability to capitalise on this temporary relief. Investors should approach the rally with caution, balancing short-term gains against long-term risks. As India navigates complex global trade dynamics, the government must ensure that protective measures like the safeguard duty foster competitiveness without unduly burdening downstream industries or consumers. The steel sector’s resilience and adaptability will determine its ability to thrive in this challenging environment.
0 Comments